I have three kinds of insulated bottles.
1. Mitsubishi. A lovely ali bottle, with an external glassfibre (?) stuffed sheath that makes it too big for any fixed bottle cages. Problem is the same as all ali bottles, that encrustrations form inside. They were cheap at pound shop and I bought a handful and chucked the current one after about 18 months. All finished now, and the only available stock is at a trendy sports shop for a very stiff price.
2. Rock-something, the outdoor brand sold by Lidl. This is a three-layer bottle. Inner and outer is plastic, and there is a foam layer friction-fit inside the outer layer. Excellent protective cap attached to inner tube. It works until you get water inside the foam and the water starts rotting and smelling. That said, mine lasted years, and after my wife washed the foam in common kitchen soap. Still using them year-round, but mostly just carry tap water in them. Doubt they'll offer all-day insulation but on summer's day here in Ireland (about the equivalent of cold winter's day in Melbourne...) I came home with ice cubes still rattling after two hours. Same size as a 750ml bottle was claimed to hold 500ml.
3. In dead of winter I do the sensible thing and use a proper Thermos. Only the smallest size fits in bottle cages, and rattles in fixed cages but works in foldover or springloaded cages like my BBB carbon bottle cage. I've never actually smashed one, but some of them have glass inside which might be vulnerable if you ride on narrow high-pressure tyres. I have two, one in stainless, one in plastic, both the gennie Thermos, both at least twenty years old and going strong. Problem is how much it actually holds: four very small cups. It's probably just as well I'm never out for more than two or three hours, most often in winter only 90 minutes. Not a touring or even all-day size. I use these for Lady Grey tea with lemon and honey, which I find invigorating on the bike in winter.
4. Actually I also have a really big hunter's Thermos, but it has to stand up in the saddle bag and peek out, so I used it only once when there was a large party cycling; very awkward and heavy. It certainly keeps a day's coffee or soup warm, but you really want a motorized vehicle to carry it in.