FrogPrince - I agree. I thought £9 was a bit steep but he does have a lot of cycle touring experience in many different climates and regions. I purchased it as a matter of interest to see if my gear collected over the years featured in this guide. It is a little repetitive in places I agree, but found it very interesting as to what his recommendations were based on his more extensive experience.
Having done a three month tour round the North Sea Cycle Route, I was after another perspective for longer more extreme tours. In that respect I did find some interesting nuggets. For someone setting out on their first, or a long trans-continental ride, it could be a useful resource.
I was a bit miffed about his discussion on Thorn bikes where he seems to play down the Rohloff hub due to expense. I managed to get my Raven Tour less than half price, and cheaper than a less sturdy derailleur steed. He is right in a way, just grab any bike and set off (as many have done). He did not however explain other virtues of the Rohloff such as being able to change gear while not pedalling or from a stationary start. I may tell him off (as feedback) via email
Yes! No mention of the Helinox Chair which I have too and enjoyed greatly every night camping for three months. I would happily take it again on any tour. He is a lot younger as you said so maybe the chair idea has not crossed his mind yet. It will one day!
After reading his guide I am happy with the gear I ended up with and it gave me confidence that some of the stuff I have would be up to a longer more extreme tour. It made me reflect on what I did or did not need on a long tour. Then again when you set off that becomes very obvious very quickly!
I have a sleeping bag that was given to me in France, as well as an ancient cheap tent with holes in it that still works well and was one of the few than didn't blow away in a huge thunder storm last summer! No need for lots of fancy gear in the end.
I can also understand his philosophy of making do in order to prevent the cost of equipment preventing anyone from setting off on the big adventure.
Not totally defending the guide but I found some information of use.