Just a thought...
Your Number One choice is well-proven among members of this Forum, jags.
The old Packard automobile slogan was "Ask the man who owns one". It works for bicycles, too. Correctly choosing a new bicycle for oneself in the absence of a test ride is much easier if there is a lot of user feedback on how well the model works. The Club Tour has that in spades, virtually all of it positive.
The other bikes in your list are all fine machines -- no doubt there -- but don't have the depth of feedback or community resources of the Thorn. That really does count for a lot when buying an unknown frame or bike.
Best,
Dan.