71
Belt Drive / Re: Belt drive article from Thorn Blog
« Last post by Andre Jute on February 14, 2026, 07:10:00 PM »2 - If I ever get a purpose-built electric bike. But, when the time comes that I need assistance, at the moment my plan is to convert one of my existing bikes, or perhaps a second-hand mountain bike (available for about 50 euros), and use a chain, chainring and sprocket designed specifically for electric bikes together with a ChainGlider. These KMC transmission components cost significantly morer than standard ones, but still a lot less than belt drive components.
I agree with you, Martin. Having discovered the Chainglider and the KMC X8 chain, and steel chainrings, I have zero interest in the frame-weakening a belt drive brings with it. It may be that I'm biased by having been a motor racer as a young man, whose specialty was suspensions, which absolutely demand stiff frames. But I'm not convinced by the special electric bike components KMC are marketing.
I discovered steel chainrings serendipitously: I was ready to order a Utopia Kranich but hated the amorphous cranks that was their standard supply, and had been put off the aluminum chainrings that went with the ugly cranks when I used Nexus transmission from Shimano, which ate itself up pretty shortly; I never saw as much as thousand miles from a set. I thought about the Thorn default chainring which then as now had a pretty good reputation of longevity, until I discovered it wouldn't fit in Utopia's Country chain enclosure (same principle as the Hebie's Chainglider but much lighter build). Someone suggested I fit a temporary cheap steel crankset from India, Amar brand, until found a way to buy a set of the Japanese cranks I had my heart set on. It was many months before I found a way of actually having the cranks I wanted delivered to me, from Paris as it happened, and not too long after that a lot of things happened simultaneously: I moved up the steepest hill in town, the Country chain protector started falling apart, I discovered the Chainglider, I bought a not too outrageously expensive electric bike kit to educate myself, and I discovered that the only really satisfactory upmarket chainring inside a Chainglider is Surly's stainless steel model. After about 3500 miles the black paint on the Amar was still intact. When I went from a front-drive to a mid-drive electric motor the Surly chainring couldn't be made to fit, so I got a couple of sizes of 8Fun's standard steel chainrings, dished to fit over their motor to give the right tread width for the Rohloff, both in steel. The chainring that on test I found most suitable has since done 11000 miles inside a Chainglider without any sign of wear. It follows logically that I see zero reason to fit anything more expensive than steel on a utility or touring bike -- I presume a road bike someone intends to race would be built to a more weight-conscious decision pyramid.

Recent Posts